British Society for Phenomenology
Menu

New Essay: Matthew J. Barnard & Keith Crome on AI & Education

Future Humanities: an open-access journal – ‘The Plagiarist in the Machine? Generative AI and the Will to Fail’ – First published: 12 June 2026.

The Plagiarist in the Machine? Generative AI and the Will to Fail

Matthew J. Barnard, Keith Crome
First published: 12 June 2026 – Future Humanities

This paper argues that the real challenge posed by Large Language Models (LLMs) in Higher Education lies not in their potential for plagiarism, but in their creation of a new form of writing that is indistinguishable in the traditional essay. Only through a phenomenological analysis of the writing process can the genuine difference become perceptible. We contrast the lived experience of traditional composition with that of chatbot-assisted generation, revealing how the latter alters the writer’s relation to anxiety, authorship and failure. Both the concerns surrounding LLMs and their uncritical embrace, we suggest, share a Cartesian illusion: that the mind might be freed from the body’s drudgery, and that thinking could be detached from the act of writing itself along with the risk of its failure. In displacing effort and vulnerability, the chatbot offers a false promise of liberation that mirrors the instrumental logic of the contemporary university. Higher education, already redefined as the cultivation of marketable skills for individual advancement, thus confronts a deeper crisis: the obsolescence of the very practices through which it claims to form intellect and character. The essay, as both form and assessment, becomes the site of this crisis—caught between obsolescence and the diminishing will to fail.

Original paper – Open Access: https://doi.org/10.1002/fhu2.70030

Matthew J. Barnard (Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester UK)

Keith Crome (Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester UK)

Future Humanities publishes trans- and inter-disciplinary research on the rise of new humanities, focusing on their subjects, methodology, and public dimensions. The journal’s coverage includes, but is not limited to, philosophy, cultural and historical studies, religious studies, linguistics and semiotics, literature, and arts and creative practises. The editors encourage submissions of scholarly articles, state-of-the-field reviews, replication studies, null findings, and more. As an open-access journal, the aim is to be author- and reader-friendly, with quick review and publication times, free format submission, and a transparent approach to peer-review.

Edited by Daan Oostveen and Francesco Tava