Structuralism, Phenomenology & The ‘Great Quarrel’ for Cinematic Sense
Online Talk: Corey Cribb – BAFTSS Film & Philosophy SIG TALK – Monday 31 August – Teams.
BAFTSS Film & Philosophy SIG TALK
Structuralism, Phenomenology & The ‘Great Quarrel’ for Cinematic Sense
Corey Cribb
Monday August 31st @ 5pm
Please join the BAFTSS Film & Philosophy SIG TALK on Teams at 5pm on Monday 31st of August for Corey Cribb’s Talk “Structuralism, Phenomenology & the ‘Great Quarrel’ for Cinematic Sense”
Abstract: Summarising what he views as the central wager of the film theoretical tradition that runs from Jean Epstein to Gilles Deleuze critiqued in his book Film Fables, Jacques Rancière has claimed that: “[T]he art of moving images provides access to an inner truth of the sensible that settles the quarrels for priority among the arts and among the senses because it settles, first and foremost, the great quarrel between thought and sensibility” (2006, p. 2). While for Rancière film theory has time and again attached the philosophical importance of the moving image to its ‘sensible effects’, or affectivity, at the expense of its intelligibility, a brief glance at the annals of French film theory reveals that, far from settled, this ‘great quarrel’ animated film theoretical debate throughout the second half of the twentieth century. In this presentation I will revisit the intellectual struggle between French-language phenomenological and semiological film theories as they developed from the 1940s to the 1980s. In seeking to account for cinematic meaning, these two traditions – I argue – anchored cinematic meaning to the sensible and the intelligible respectively thereby exposing film theory to one of the most ancient philosophical questions: namely the relationship between sense perception and knowledge. Drawing on materials from my in-progress monograph Film and the Philosophy of Sense, I will outline the development of this problem from Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s 1945 lecture “Film and the New Psychology” to the critiques of structuralism put forward by Deleuze and Marie-Claire Ropars in the 1980s.
Bio: Corey P. Cribb is a Government of Ireland Postdoctoral Fellow at Technological University Dublin. His in-progress monograph, Film and the Philosophy of Sense (under contract with SUNY Press), analyses French language debates over cinematic meaning, or ‘sense,’ from the 1940s to the present, with a focus on the film theoretical writings of Gilles Deleuze, Marie-Claire Ropars, Jean-Luc Nancy and Jacques Rancière. He is co-editor of the 2025 anthology Far from the Masters: Experimentations in Post-New Wave French Cinema (Index Press) and of a 2024 special issue of Transformations on idealism and film theory.
Microsoft Teams meeting
Join: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/357007437554575?p=BuBDFka8lDgZya56oq
Meeting ID: 357 007 437 554 575
Passcode: zP2ks9w5