Call for Abstracts: Early Phenomenology on ‘Position-Taking’ – UC Louvain 2027
“Early Phenomenology on ‘Position-Taking’ (Stellungnahme). Theoretical Stance, Emotional Response, and the Constitution of the Person” – UCLouvain, Belgium, 17–19 March 2027.
Call for Abstracts: “Early Phenomenology on ‘Position-Taking’ (Stellungnahme). Theoretical Stance, Emotional Response, and the Constitution of the Person”
UCLouvain, Belgium, 17–19 March 2027
Organizing committee: Alexis Delamare (University College Dublin/ULiège) & Élise Dravigny (UCLouvain/Sorbonne Université)
Scientific committee: Sylvain Camilleri (UCLouvain), Alexis Delamare (University College Dublin/ULiège), Arnaud Dewalque (ULiège), Élise Dravigny (UCLouvain/Sorbonne Université), Bruno Leclercq (ULiège), Marc Maesschalck (UCLouvain), Denis Seron (ULiège)
Theme and scope of the conference
“Now the question is how we want to fix the concept of position-taking. It is not so easy” (Edmund Husserl, Ms A VI 31, 42a, 1928)
This conference aims to shed new light on the intriguing concept of Stellungnahme (usually translated as “position-taking”) as it is applied by early phenomenologists, especially by Edmund Husserl and the so-called ‘Munich-Göttingen’ Circle of phenomenology, composed of Johannes Daubert, Dietrich von Hildebrand, Roman Ingarden, Alexander Pfänder, Adolf Reinach, Max Scheler, and Edith Stein, among others.
Within early phenomenology, the term Stellungnahme is first employed in a published work by Reinach in “Zur Theorie des negativen Urteils” (1911; 1982). There, it characterizes those mental experiences, such as belief, striving, or love, which display an inherent polarity (being respectively opposed to disbelief, struggle, and hate) – in contrast to representations or meanings. Reinach then takes up this concept in 1912 in his essay on “reflection” (Überlegung) (1912; 1913), in which he emphasizes that intellectual reflection necessarily aims to establish a “position-taking”, typically a conviction about a state of affairs (2017, 58–65).
Soon after, clearly drawing on Reinach, von Hildebrand elaborates his own original approach to Stellungnahme, through its cardinal distinction with Kenntnisnahme or “knowledge-taking” (von Hildebrand 1916, 134). A knowledge-taking, such as the vision of a landscape, is characterized as a mere “having” of a content, whereas, in the case of a Stellungnahme, I take a spontaneous stance with respect to the appearing object. In this regard, intellectual experiences such as conviction, but also affective experiences such as joy or indignation and conative experiences such as willing, insofar as they exhibit such subjective activity, are to be interpreted as ‘position-takings’.
Especially in his manuscripts from the Studien zur Struktur des Bewusstseins, Edmund Husserl also makes extensive and yet-to-be-explored use of the concept of Stellungnahme. In the theoretical sphere, he notably distinguishes between ‘position-taking’ understood as a positional act – in contrast to neutral ‘mere representations’ (1980, 446–47) – and ‘position-taking’ understood as a critical procedure aiming at the rational verification of a certain thesis (2020a, 331, 372). In the affective sphere, he observes that the manifestation of a positive value often motivates an “affective position-taking” (Gemütsstellungnahme) as a response, whereby the subject actively “turns” towards the object with pleasure (2020b, 121). Lastly, Husserl emphasizes the crucial role played by sedimented active ‘position-takings’ in the constitution of a stable personal self (1952, 112–13).
Finally, Edith Stein also appeals to the terminology of ‘position-taking’ in her 1922 Beiträge zur philosophischen Begründung der Psychologie und der Geisteswissenschaften (2010, 49, 133). Following von Hildebrand and Husserl, she asserts that an emotion – for instance, joy – is not a “knowledge-taking of the value” (Wertkenntnisnahme) – for instance of beauty – but rather a subjective stance towards the axiological object, and thus a “response” (Antwort) thereto.
The concept of Stellungnahme thus assumes a variety of functions within early phenomenology. This variety reveals the richness and power of this notion, whose applications range from theoretical philosophy to the philosophy of emotion and to ethics; yet it also challenges the unity of this concept and calls into question the compatibility of these diverse uses, across authors and within the work of particular phenomenologists – e.g., Husserl.
Against this background, the aim of this meeting is to advance the literature – whose (scarce) accounts of Stellungnahme have been limited to individual authors (Carta and Delamare, forthcoming; Delamare 2025; De Monticelli 2011; Jacobs 2016; Jardine 2020; Loidolt 2021; Magrì 2022; Müller 2020; Salice 2015; Uemura and Salice 2019) – by offering an overview of ‘position-taking’ among early phenomenologists. To do so, the first objective is to study the influences, continuities, and tensions between the accounts they propose. Emphasis will also be placed on the sources of the concept of Stellungnahme. In particular, the psychologist Hugo Münsterberg (a student of Wundt) already uses this term in his Grundzüge der Psychologie (1900), seemingly with a meaning very close to Reinach’s. In addition, in his 1911 essay, Reinach explicitly refers to the works of Windelband (1884) and to Brentano’s theory of judgment (Brentano 1874, 262). Finally, a third line of inquiry will be the potential relevance of this terminology for contemporary issues, such as epistemic agency (Jacobs 2021) or the reactional nature of emotions (Müller 2018).
Submission guidelines
- Please send your abstracts as attachments (Word or PDF) to both elise.dravigny@uclouvain.be and alexis.delamare@ucd.ie
- Abstract length: max. 600 words (bibliography excluded, if any).
- Abstracts should be anonymized. Please include your name, affiliation, and position in the body of the email.
- Deadline for abstract submission: 30 June 2026.
- Notification of acceptance: by 15 July 2026.
Full CfP including suggested topics and bibliography: https://www.uclouvain.be/fr/instituts-recherche/isp/news/colloque-international-early-phenomenology-on-position-taking
For any inquiries, please contact alexis.delamare@ucd.ie or elise.dravigny@uclouvain.be